Bondi Beach is a warning Canada cannot ignore

Commentary

A tribute to shooting victims at Sydney’s Bondi Beach, Dec. 15, 2025, a day after a shooting. Mark Baker/AP Photo.

The massacre at Bondi Beach should not be dismissed in Canada as a distant Australian tragedy. It is a warning—one that speaks directly to the choices our own government has made and continues to make.

On the first night of Hanukkah, Australian Jews gathered to mark a festival of light and continuity. Instead, they were targeted for who they are. This attack did not come out of nowhere. It followed months in which antisemitism was allowed to metastasize in plain sight, normalized as political expression and excused as understandable anger over events abroad.

Jewish communities warned, repeatedly, that the line between protest and racial hatred had collapsed. Those warnings were met with expressions of concern, but little urgency, and with policies that reinforced the very narratives animating extremists.

Blurred lines

In Australia, as in Canada, government messaging has blurred moral lines. Rather than insisting on clarity—between a democratic state defending itself and a terrorist organization committed to Jewish annihilation—leaders have increasingly adopted language that treats Israel and Hamas as morally comparable actors. Recognition of a so-called Palestinian state, absent borders, governance, or peace, is presented as the moderate view even while Hamas remains in control in Gaza, holds hostages, and calls openly for the destruction of Israel.

View reader comments (5)

At the United Nations, Australia and Canada alike have supported resolutions that single out Israel, while soft-pedalling or erasing Hamas’ responsibility. These are not neutral acts. They signal whose conduct is to be condemned and whose is to be contextualized.

Most troubling is the willingness of both governments to lend legitimacy to the politicized misuse of international criminal law. Ottawa has signalled its readiness to enforce deeply flawed International Criminal Court arrest warrants against Israel’s prime minister and defence minister, looking to put leaders of a democratic state in the dock while Hamas’ leadership remains beyond reach. This inversion of law and morality is celebrated by those who already believe violence against Jews can be justified as “resistance.”

Comments (5)

Jerry Grant
17 Dec 2025 @ 8:35 am

“Finally, the federal government must speak plainly.”
You would think the first step would be to clearly identify the problem. A search of the article for “Muslim”, “Islam” and “ISIS” returned no results. Two Pakistani men slaughtered 15 Jews and the only cause the author can come up with is the anodyne “antisemitism” as if the terrorists could have belonged to any demographic. Is it so hard to write “Islamists are a problem”?

Go to article
00:00:00
00:00:00